New York, November 27, 2025
Pete Alonso, the prominent MLB power hitter, is drawing intense interest from three major teams—the New York Mets, Los Angeles Angels, and Toronto Blue Jays—as the 2025-2026 free agency period unfolds, signaling a competitive pursuit marked by contract negotiations and strategic roster planning.
Primary Contenders for Alonso
The New York Mets remain a leading suitor for Alonso, his original franchise where he established himself as a cornerstone bat. Negotiations between Alonso and the Mets continue, with the team reportedly considering shifting him to a designated hitter role to leverage his offensive strengths while mitigating concerns about his defensive throwing. However, Alonso’s expectation of a minimum six-year deal faces resistance from the Mets, who have yet to narrow the gap between their offer and his demands, leaving his return uncertain but plausible given his franchise status.
Meanwhile, the Los Angeles Angels have emerged as serious contenders. Team owner Arte Moreno has expressed a strong desire to add a significant power bat to enhance the Angels’ offensive lineup, and Alonso fits this profile precisely. The Angels’ active pursuit reflects a strategic move to bolster an offense that has underperformed, making Alonso a prioritized target among their offseason acquisitions.
Toronto Blue Jays also factor prominently in Alonso’s free-agent market. The Blue Jays view Alonso as a flexible asset, capable of filling a designated hitter role in the short term, and potentially stepping in as Vladimir Guerrero Jr.’s successor at first base should Guerrero depart after the 2025 season. Toronto’s approach combines both a planned internal transition and openness to roster changes via trade, signaling a dual strategy that could pivot significantly around Alonso’s signing.
Market Constraints and Additional Interest
The market for Alonso’s talents is considered somewhat narrow due to his contract expectations and the specific fit required by teams. While the Mets, Angels, and Blue Jays lead the charge, other franchises like the San Francisco Giants and Boston Red Sox have expressed measured interest without the same urgency or public intensity. This limited pool underscores the challenges teams face in meeting Alonso’s terms while aligning with their strategic and financial frameworks.
Strategic Implications
Alonso’s power-hitting prowess makes him a valuable commodity capable of reshaping lineups. The Mets’ proposal to move him into a designated hitter role could reflect a balancing act between preserving his offensive output and addressing defensive liabilities. For the Angels, Alonso represents a long-awaited reinforcement to an offense seeking consistency and punch. The Blue Jays’ contemplation of a Guerrero Jr. trade coupled with an Alonso acquisition indicates flexibility and forward thinking in roster construction.
Looking Ahead
The 2025-26 MLB free agency period for Pete Alonso promises to be a focal event, with negotiations and decisions expected to have ripple effects across multiple franchises. Teams’ strategic responses to Alonso’s demands and potential signing will likely influence their competitiveness and operational planning for the upcoming seasons. Observers can anticipate a tightly contested pursuit reflecting broader trends in baseball free agency dynamics around power hitters with defined contractual and positional profiles.